Joe Pagnotta, Sheplers Executive and CU Athlete, Passes at 74

Joseph Michael Pagnotta, a 74-year-old resident of Castle Rock, died on October 26, 2026. He was surrounded by his wife, children, and immediate family members at the time of his passing.

Pagnotta worked his way up to become a part owner of the clothing company Sheplers. Born in Pueblo, Colorado, in 1952, he focused his career on providing opportunities for his family while taking pride in teaching and leading others.

A student-athlete at the University of Colorado, Pagnotta competed in both football and track. He remained a devoted fan of the Buffs, the Denver Broncos, and the Denver Nuggets throughout his life. He was particularly supportive of his children's athletic achievements.

He is survived by his wife, Shari; his children, Joeilyn Pagnotta, Ryan Pagnotta, and Matthew Pagnotta; and his grandchildren, Siena and Giovanni. His parents, Pete and Rose Pagnotta, and his brother, Anthony Pagnotta, died before him.

A memorial mass will take place at 10 a.m. on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. The service is scheduled at St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church in Castle Rock.