Santa Ana Police: Oversight Panel Demands Investigation Into ICE Arrests
Commissioners cited discrepancies between 911 call transcripts and police reports after federal agents requested local assistance in a sanctuary city.
By Aiko Petrov ·

The Santa Ana Police Oversight Commission has called for an independent investigation into the arrest of two immigrant advocates following a dispute with off-duty ICE agents. The move came after a review of 911 transcripts and police reports revealed conflicting accounts of the incident that occurred on October 14. Commissioner Amalia Mejia questioned the lack of urgency in the police narrative and noted that the officers did not express fear during the initial call, despite the formal report citing safety concerns as the primary reason for the response.
The incident began when off-duty federal agents requested assistance from the Santa Ana Police Department, the only sanctuary city in Orange County. The call led to the arrest of residents Madison Crabill and Adilene Tonoco for resisting a peace officer, stalking, and criminal conspiracy. Although police leaders maintain that the department does not generally cooperate with federal immigration enforcement, this specific call was accepted. State law largely prohibits local law enforcement from working with federal agencies on immigration matters, adding a layer of legal complexity to the decision to respond.
The Orange County District Attorney’s office and the city’s legal team concluded there was insufficient evidence to support the charges. A communication from the DA’s office to the police department stated that there was no proof the suspects intended to do anything other than follow the officers to let the community know of their presence. The office also noted a lack of evidence regarding past violence or weapons that would make the two women a threat to trained, armed agents. Despite this, the initial police report claimed the pair blocked the agents’ vehicle and expressed safety concerns.
Crabill highlighted several inconsistencies during the public meeting. She pointed out that the agents laughed during the 911 call and complimented the music playing in the observers’ car. One agent was heard saying he was not scared and that the observers had been doing this for days. The transcript also recorded agents describing the observers as obnoxious and agitators, noting they had recognized them from federal operations in La Habra that same day. Crabill stated she was arrested around the time she needed to administer an insulin shot and was subsequently taken to a hospital.
Deputy Chief Roland Andrade said the department is currently reviewing its procedures and reassessing how it handles calls from federal agents. He explained that responding officers did not hear the 911 call themselves but relied on information passed down by the watch commander. Andrade stated that future responses will be evaluated based on whether there is a threat to life, acknowledging that the department must balance its role in a sanctuary city with the need to assist callers for service. He also noted that the department has held extensive training sessions on when to assist and when to decline.
Police Chief Robert Rodriguez wrote in a Friday email that the department respects the district attorney’s decision not to file charges. He stated that the incident has raised concerns within the community and that the department recognizes the need to examine its actions. Rodriguez noted that the approach to similar situations has already evolved to reflect lessons learned from this specific event. He emphasized that the department continually evaluates its responses to incidents, regardless of whether a formal complaint is received.
Commission Chair Keith Carpenter argued that the police should not categorize callers based on their affiliation. He stated that a call for service is a call for service and that separating people into different response categories is not a wise decision. Commissioner Carlos Perea expressed disappointment that Chief Rodriguez did not attend the meeting to address the discrepancies personally. Perea noted that both the city attorney’s analysis and the DA’s rejection of the case undermine the department’s initial justification for pressing charges against the two advocates.






