Judge Keeps Alex Murdaugh Murder Charges Alive Ahead of April Retrial
A South Carolina judge rejected a bid to toss the original indictments, ruling that errors by the lead investigator do not negate the other evidence in the case.
By Lorenzo Marshall ·

Judge Debra McCaslin ruled on Friday that the original murder indictments against Alex Murdaugh will stand, clearing the path for his retrial scheduled for April. The decision ends a legal challenge that sought to void the charges based on testimony given by the case's chief investigator to a grand jury in 2022.
The ruling follows a hearing held on Nov. 13, where Murdaugh's legal team spent nearly an hour arguing that the evidence base for the indictments was flawed. The defense focused on statements made by David Owen, a former State Law Enforcement Division agent who led the investigation. Owen told the Colleton County grand jury that blood spatter was found on a T-shirt Murdaugh wore on the night of the killings. An earlier report from state agents indicated no such blood stains existed, and that specific evidence was never introduced during the initial trial.
Defense attorney Jim Griffin argued that the blood spatter claim was the only piece of testimony linking Murdaugh to the location and time of the murders. Griffin stated that neither a phone call nor video footage placed Murdaugh at the scene. He asserted that the blood from his murdered son, Paul, was the evidence that placed Murdaugh there. Griffin noted that the false claim about the T-shirt was the only thing anyone heard that could connect the suspect to the crime.
McCaslin wrote in her order that any mistakes by Owen were not intentional. She stated that other evidence was sufficient to support the indictments despite the inconsistencies. The judge expressed disappointment that Owen did not read a report stating there was no blood on the T-shirt before presenting his case to the grand jury. She wrote that law enforcement has a fundamental duty to accurately represent the complete evidentiary record and that such oversights undermine public confidence in the criminal justice system.
The judge determined that questions regarding inconsistencies in the evidence are matters for trial and cross examination rather than grounds for dismissal. Prosecutors countered that a single mistake does not constitute bad faith and that ample other evidence supports the charges. They cited video recorded by Paul Murdaugh in which Alex Murdaugh's voice is heard at the scene, contradicting his denials. Prosecutors also pointed to the family's mounting debts and the fact that Murdaugh's schemes to steal from clients and his law firm were nearing discovery.
The South Carolina Supreme Court vacated Murdaugh's convictions and life sentence in May after ruling that a court clerk improperly influenced jurors during his 2023 trial. Murdaugh, 58, is currently serving a separate sentence of decades in prison for stealing millions of dollars from clients. He has admitted in court to being a thief, an insurance cheat, a bad lawyer, and a longtime opioid addict, though he continues to deny being a killer. Prosecutors maintain that he killed his wife, Maggie, and his son, Paul, in 2021 on their property in the South Carolina Lowcountry to buy time to cover up his financial thefts.
The original trial concluded with a conviction for the double murder. The new proceeding will focus on whether the remaining evidence is enough to secure a verdict now that the specific blood spatter claim has been scrutinized. The retrial is set to begin in April, with the same core allegations of malice and premeditation.






