How The Verge Vets Black Friday Deals Amid Growing Doubts About Online Discounts
Facing a flood of promotional pitches and research showing many advertised discounts are misleading, The Verge says it applies strict internal standards before recommending any Black Friday deal.
By Lorenzo Marshall ·

In the month leading up to Black Friday, the biggest shopping day of the year in the United States, The Verge says it has been inundated with dozens of press releases a day from brands large and small hoping to have their offers publicized. According to the publication, most companies would prefer that no research be done into whether the deals are actually good, and few provide the context needed to vet them.
New research helps explain why that caution may be warranted. Groundwork Collaborative recently published findings on the unclear way Amazon displays deals. Its researchers tracked a selection of products ahead of Black Friday and Cyber Monday in 2024 and 2025 and found that nearly one in three products advertised as deals on Amazon did not offer savings during the actual shopping events. The investigation also found that nearly a tenth of the deals examined were more expensive during the sales events than on some days in the month before them.
One common tactic The Verge says it tries to correct for in its coverage is the inflated discount claim, where the original list price is set higher than the usual day-to-day price to make the savings appear more substantial. Sometimes the price shown is the manufacturer's suggested retail price, though that is not always the case.
In a recent statement to investigative journalist Ronan Farrow, an unattributed Amazon spokesperson said the company's List Price can be aggregated from the past 90 to 180 days of prices, rather than the past 30 days as Groundwork Collaborative's research states, and is based on prices from Amazon itself and competing retailers. The Verge notes that, in its experience, confusing pricing and discount communication is not limited to Amazon.
The publication says vetting deals is a large but invisible part of its work year round, and that most of what it is pitched never appears on the site because it fails to meet its standards. Even a deal on a product its staff has tested and genuinely likes, described as its north star for coverage, is not guaranteed to be featured. Deals may be skipped if they recur every week, last only a few hours, require a premium membership, or are offered by a retailer none of the staff has heard of or shopped at.
The basic criteria, the publication explains, are whether its writers like a product enough to cover it and whether the price has dropped, followed by an assessment of whether the discount is genuinely worth a shopper's attention. That judgment has grown more complicated over the past year, as the RAM price surge known as RAMageddon and the ripple effects of higher tariffs have, in some cases, substantially raised prices. For products hit by those hikes, new deal prices sometimes amount to little more than the original sticker price, which The Verge acknowledges may still technically count as savings for buyers trying to cut costs wherever possible. It also sometimes highlights discounted gift cards as a way to save on in-demand items, describing them as the only way to get any kind of deal on Grand Theft Auto VI before launch.
To monitor price drops, the publication relies on free tracking tools such as CamelCamelCamel and Keepa, which provide an independent read on Amazon's historical pricing and send alerts when favored products go on sale. Amazon offers its own Alexa for Shopping tool, which can show up to a year of pricing data and perform AI chatbot-like actions, including automatically buying products on a user's behalf. The Verge says Amazon's historical pricing data usually aligns with third-party tools, but none of them are perfect, and even the independent trackers sometimes fail to display record-low prices it has covered.
Despite casting a wide net across product categories ahead of the holidays, The Verge says that of the thousands of deals it has reviewed ahead of Black Friday, only a few dozen standouts meet its criteria. Those picks, spanning headphones, TVs, gaming accessories, smart home tech and more, are products its staff has tested or used personally and considers good items at noteworthy prices.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






