Prosecutors allege West Allis husband planned his wife's 2024 basement fall
Benjamin Carpenter faces a first-degree intentional homicide charge in the death of Erica Carpenter, who died after falling down basement stairs in October 2024.
By Aiko Petrov ·

West Allis police are investigating a two-year-old death that they now believe was a planned killing. Prosecutors filed charges on Nov. 17 against Benjamin Carpenter, who was arrested that same day.
The criminal complaint alleges that Carpenter committed first-degree intentional homicide. Erica Carpenter died from head injuries sustained in October 2024. The incident occurred at the couple's home near South 95th and West Dakota streets in West Allis.
Police began their investigation on Oct. 13, 2024, after a welfare check request. Officers arrived at the residence around 10:30 p.m. that night. Carpenter told investigators that he and his wife were doing laundry in the basement. He stated that Erica collapsed and hit her head "mildly hard." Carpenter claimed he slipped while carrying her up the stairs, causing both of them to fall.
According to the complaint, the fall sent Erica crashing into the cinder block wall at the bottom of the stairs. She was transported to a hospital but later died from her injuries. The state now argues that the fall was not an accident but a premeditated act by Carpenter.
The West Allis Police Department is asking for public assistance. Anyone with information regarding Erica A. Carpenter's death should call 414-302-8000.






