New Mexico frees 65-year-old Carl Case after 44 years in prison
Judge Lisa Riley vacated the 1982 murder conviction of Nancy Mitchell based on new testimony, but the state has filed an appeal.
By Harper Foster ·

The release of a long-imprisoned inmate from the Penitentiary of New Mexico on October 27 ended a legal battle spanning four decades. Carl Case, 65, walked out of the facility south of Santa Fe after state District Judge Lisa Riley determined he had proven his actual innocence. The court order reversed a 1982 conviction for the rape and murder of 16-year-old Nancy Mitchell.
Case was 21 when he was sentenced to life plus 18 years in October 1982. He was convicted alongside Joseph Brown and Curtis Worley. Juvenile Michael Tweedy was prosecuted separately and released just before his 21st birthday. The original verdict relied on the testimony of three young witnesses. Mitchell’s body was found on a small island in the Pecos River in Eddy County on January 30, 1982. An autopsy determined she died of exposure three to six weeks prior to discovery.
Legal challenges began in 1999 when April Land, founder of the New Mexico Innocence and Justice Project, took up the case. Land described the original file as smelling to high heaven. The effort gained momentum in 2003 after witness Audrey Knight told Worley’s father she had fabricated her testimony. Witness Paul Dunlap also admitted his account was false. Law students located a 1982 cassette tape of Bobby Autry’s interview with sheriff’s deputies, which had sat in a box for decades. Autry committed suicide in July 2006.
A federal judge granted Case a new trial in 2011, but an appellate court overturned that ruling. In 2012, Case passed a polygraph test with results described as resoundingly in favor of his innocence. In 2019, Judge Jane Shuler-Gray vacated Worley’s sentences, a decision the state Supreme Court later reversed. Brown’s petition for a new trial was rejected in the same year. Worley died in prison in November 2025.
The final evidentiary hearing took place in Carlsbad in October 2025. Tweedy testified before Judge Riley that prosecutor James W. Klipstine Jr. had offered him immunity for testifying against his co-defendants. Tweedy stated he refused the offer and knew nothing about Mitchell’s death. Judge Riley issued her ruling on August 25, finding that Case had met the standard for actual innocence based on the new evidence.
The New Mexico Department of Justice appealed Riley’s ruling on October 26. Despite the pending appeal, the judge ordered Case’s release the following day. Case is currently living at a ranch in Clayton with a former caseworker and her husband. He faces the possibility of being sent back to prison if the appeal succeeds. The financial and administrative costs of the appeal remain with the state department.
Joseph Brown remains incarcerated. His attorney requested a pardon from Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham on November 12. Brown is suffering from bladder cancer. The Governor’s Office directed his attorney to submit a formal application for the pardon.
More Business · Watch Your Wallet · Report a business · Got a Story?






