Bishops push for church access in ICE detention and challenge suicide laws
Leaders at the USCCB assembly in Baltimore detail legal battles over sacraments for detainees and state aid in dying statutes.
By Lorenzo Marshall ·

Catholic leaders in the United States are focusing legal and public attention on two specific areas of religious liberty. These issues involve the right of clergy to provide sacraments to people detained by federal immigration authorities and the impact of state laws permitting physician-assisted suicide. Bishops discussed these priorities during the fall plenary assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which took place in Baltimore from Nov. 16 to 19.
Archbishop Alexander K. Sample of Portland, Oregon, chairs the USCCB Committee for Religious Liberty. He stated that the church is concerned about ensuring detainees have access to pastoral care. Sample noted that the ministry to incarcerated individuals is long-standing, but the current situation presents a different reality because many detainees are active members of local parishes. He described these individuals as being taken from their communities and placed in detention centers.
The Archdiocese of St. Louis recently filed a lawsuit against the federal government. The suit challenges a policy that the archdiocese says prevents priests from distributing Communion and hearing confessions for ICE detainees. Bishop Brendan J. Cahill of Joliet, Illinois, identified this pastoral care as a key concern. He argued that visiting the imprisoned is one of the seven corporal works of mercy and that the church has a right to practice its religion in this manner.
Separate legal actions are underway in Illinois and New York regarding physician-assisted suicide. In Illinois, a federal judge has temporarily blocked the state from forcing Catholic entities to aid terminally ill adults in dying. The plaintiffs are working to make this block permanent. In New York, Archbishop Ronald A. Hicks joined four orders of nuns and other ministries in challenging the state’s Medical Aid in Dying Act, which took effect on Aug. 5. A federal judge issued a temporary restraining order to prevent the state from enforcing the law against these Catholic plaintiffs.
Archbishop Hicks said that forcing religious sisters to consider suicide as an end-of-life option for patients is unconstitutional. He cited data from the Canadian government stating that about 16,500 people died by physician-assisted suicide in 2024. This figure represented approximately 5% of total deaths in the country that year. Hicks argued that the practice has real-life consequences and that the church should not be forced to participate in them.
Archbishop Sample noted that Oregon was the first U.S. state to legalize the practice. He said the law has had a corrosive effect over the last three decades. Sample added that the issue affects the culture’s view of the dignity of human life, particularly for the elderly. He emphasized that the bishops are concerned with protecting religious liberty for all traditions, not just Catholics. Sample said that when religious liberty is threatened for one group, it is threatened for everyone.






